Customers Rock!

A blog about customers, their experiences, and how businesses can make sure their customer experiences rock!

Where Did My Dress Go?

Posted by Becky Carroll on January 29, 2007

shopping-cart.jpgI am generally a fan of Coldwater Creek.  They focus on their customers, they provide great customer service, and they use a variety of techniques, including mystery shopping, to make sure they stay on top of their customer experience.  I have personally had some fantastic customer experiences shopping there, as well as two very different retail experiences doing volunteer mystery shopping for Coldwater Creek (yes, I will post on those in the near future).  Today, I want to share a rant about Coldwater Creek’s online experience as well as share a few suggestions from which all online retailers can learn.

As Kevin Hillstrom notes in his post, Coldwater Creek has made a successful transition from catalog to retail/online.  They are good at using their email lists to send out relevant promotions to their customers.  Towards the end of each month, I get a flurry of emails from Coldwater Creek about items in their online Outlet store.  Last week, as I was perusing my morning email, the deals looked especially good, so I clicked through from the email to their outlet site.  There were 17 pages of items to go through.  In the first few pages, I did find a number of items that were screamin’ deals — a velvet dress with a sparkly brooch, a silk tank top, and a stretchy t-shirt.  I put those items in my cart and clicked “Keep Shopping”. 

Unfortunately, most of the items I clicked on took me to a page that said, “Sorry, this item is no longer available.”    OK, so the East Coast shoppers had a head start (I am in California), but this isn’t very customer-friendly. 

Website tip #1: Don’t show me an item and then make me click-through to find out it is no longer available.  If an item isn’t available, make sure it is removed from the web page.  Better: Let me see all the items that are (truly) available, in my size, and all on one long page if I want (rather than 17 separate pages of 25 items each).

To continue the story, I moved through the shopping pages quickly and found one more item I liked (a silvery belt) and put it in my cart.  This brought up my empty cart!  It did have a note in it which stated that items which had now sold out had been removed from my cart (which was all of my items).  What?!  Those were my items!  Now, I don’t know how shopping cart software works, but if I had been shopping in my local Coldwater Creek, I would not expect someone to come up to me, take my items from my arms, and tell me someone else was checking out before me who wanted these exact same items.  From looking at the forums at, an online shopping deal site, I am not the only one frustrated by this.  Some customer posts on the forum expressed a distrust of Coldwater Creek’s ability to follow through on anything from their web store.

Website tip #2: To be successful at moving customers to an online shopping experience, we need to consider their offline shopping habits.  Most customers won’t care how your online shopping cart works; they will only care that they can purchase their desired items.

Needless to say, I didn’t purchase the one item I had just put in my cart.  I closed the window in disgust and emailed Coldwater Creek’s customer service department.   I shared the situation with them, I shared my dissatisfaction with them (politely!), and I then asked them whether this occurs regularly with their shopping carts.

Less than two hours later, I received this reply:

Dear Ms. Carroll,

Thank you very much for contacting us.  It is wonderful to hear from you!

We are very glad that you decided to write to us today and share your thoughts about our website, Ms. Carroll.  Your e-mail has been forwarded to the appropriate department for review.  You are very important to us.  We look forward to serving you in the future.

We appreciate the time you have taken to write to us today.  If you have any further questions please visit our web site at or call us at 1-800-510-2808.  It is always a privilege to serve you.


Sue, Coldwater Creek Customer Service

While this is a very cordial email, and more friendly than most form letters, it does not give any indication that a person has actually read my concerns. 

Website tip #3: When you are responding to unhappy customers, acknowledge your customer’s concerns and reassure them that a person will get back to them.  Then, do it! 

Coldwater Creek, I am glad you consider it such a privilege to serve me.  Now, can I please have my dress back?


9 Responses to “Where Did My Dress Go?”

  1. Some online retailers leave items posted online if they plan on running those items next year. If they run out after selling 10,000 units, they leave the item online, so they can count how many people might have purchased it (maybe 15,000, as an example). Armed with that information, they know how many units to purchase next year.

    Online retailers tend to not do this. Retailers with a catalog heritage sometimes do this.

    It does not make for a good short-term customer experience — the retailer hopes it will help serve future customers.

  2. Kevin,

    Thanks for your insight; you certainly have a great perspective given your background! It might explain a little bit of the behavior; however, so many items had run out that I am not sure this was their strategy.

    Taking items out of a cart is not customer friendly. Thanks for the comment. 🙂

  3. Five Star Monitor

    Your wedding day is one of the most important days of your life. Not only does your wedding day have enormous emotional significance, but it also represents months of planning and preparation – and a significant financial cost. Friends and loved…

  4. Judy said

    On January 11, 2008, I order two items on CC’s outlet website. These were to be gifts, and needed as soon as they were shipped. I received a confirmation of order, along with a confirmation number. Today, January 23, 2008, I decided it was past time to track my order. Imagine my shock when I typed in my order number, and the status of my order was shown as ‘not picked’. I immediately called the toll free number to inquire just what that meant. It actually means that the items were not available and would not be shipped in spite of my confirmation order and confirmation number to the contrary. It appears to me they have absolutely no way of tracking all current and available inventory, and to hell with the customer. I was not contacted in any manner about the sudden unavailabily of these items. I had evidently needlessly provided credit info,
    shipping, etc. to them. From all appearances, my order was to be shipped the day I ordered. What a sham for a website – and what a terrible waste of my time. I did receive some generic email response from their customer service rep this morning. What a waste of their time. I have done a tremendous amount of shopping at the CC stores in two different states, but I will shop elsewhere. The retail stores and the internet store are one and the same to me.
    They are both Coldwater Creek.

  5. Donna said

    I have had the same experiences as Judy…and even further. I purchased two items, received confirmation, had it run through my credit card only to go back to check on my order to discover Coldwater Creek canceled my order with out any explaination…it is hit and miss with their online ordering. I have been told that only their “live”
    representatives have real time ordering screens to see what inventory is actually available when an order is placed.
    So, unfortunately internet shoppers have to call in to really find out if they are going to get the item they order.
    I love Coldwater Creeks merchandise, but who has time for such a stressful mess.

  6. […] Where Did My Dress Go? « Customers Rock!A blog about customers, their experiences, and how businesses can make sure their customer experiences rock! … Coldwater Creek, I am glad you consider it such a privilege to serve me.  Now, can I please have my dress back? […]

  7. voip reviews cnet…

    […]Where Did My Dress Go? « Customers Rock![…]…

  8. It’s a nice beneficial bit of information and facts. I’m just happy which you discussed this useful details around. Remember to stop us knowledgeable like this. Thank you giving.

  9. msdx said

    Aw, this was an exceptionally nice post. Finding the time and actual effort to generate a great article…
    but what can I say… I put things off a whole lot and never seem
    to get anything done.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: